View Facsimile
56
___________________________________________________________________
And subscribe our selves your distressed brethren members of the
first Church of Boston
Dated at Boston 31 March 1669
Will Davis Peter Oliver Tho: Savage Edward Ranson
Hez Usher John Hull Jos. Bock Josh Scottow
Rob: Walker Jos: Belknap Theop. Steacy Edwd Raimsford
John Wing Benj: Gibbs Jos: Davis Josh. Belsher
James Pemberton Jno Alden Wm. Salbec John Sanford
Peter Beckett Benj: Thurston Wm: Dawes Tho: Brattle
Jno Tappin Jacob Elliot Theod. Attkinson Seth Perey
The Church of Rowley did send S. P. thinking because Ipswich sent only
their two Teaching Elders that there would be none but such ther
but ther was as many if not more of brethren then of Elders from
the 13 churches they sent unto
The Councill was very unanimous in their determination that ye
dissenting brethren ought lovingly to be dismissed and in case the ch
should refuse to dismiss them after intreating & sufficient time
of waghting they were to declare their secession or withdraw
ing from them
The Reasons they desired a dismission were amongst others
thes two 1 That Mr Davenport[49] held forth doctrines as touching the child:
of Gods ch contrary to the Synod as to what they had bin taught Now the Apostles
have
charge to follow ther fayth yt spoaken to us ye word of ye lord Heb 13. 7.
2 In that he had noe call to be at Boston for as much as Newhaven never
did give their consent (nor saw ground soe to do) to his leaving of them as
appeared to ye councill by several letters: yet Boston first church went on
in electing Mr. Davenport & he accepted and that ye way might seem ye
clearer they had a letter of dismission from N. Haven. But what it was
appears by what followes
The Testimony of many of ye ministers of ye gospell in the
Massachusets Colony in N. E. against the Scandall given by
the present Elders of the first Church in Boston by their
fraudulent dealing about the letters sent from the Church
of New Haven to the Church of Boston dated ye 15 of
the 5th month 1669.
Wee being justly offended at the great & publick Scandall of Unfaythfull
=ness & falshood committed by the three Revrd Elders of the first church
in Boston, to the great dishonour of God, the Scandall of our profession
the reproach of N. England, & of the Elders in particular, desiring to be
found mourners in Zion for the same, And not perceiving as yet
any suitable repentance for it: Least we our selves & or churches & ye
countrey should be involved in the guilt therof if now full & open testi
mony should be given against it beyond any that we have yet heard
of
[49] John Davenport, former minister of New Haven, Connecticut, who moved to First Church, Boston, but was opposed by a faction of the church. Cooper, Tenacious of Their Liberties, 100-3.