Preface

These volumes constitute the fourth and fifth in a series published by the Colonial Society of Massachusetts devoted to early records of Harvard College. Volumes xv and xvi, edited by Albert Matthews and issued in 1925, contain the surviving College Records Books for the period 1636 to 1750. In his long and carefully detailed introduction, Matthews throws light on many aspects of the College’s history during this time; he has placed future students of the records deeply in his debt. The index too is unusually thorough, in part because identifications are not made in the text, where footnotes refer to textual matters only. Volume xxxi (1935) contains a number of Harvard documents, edited by several persons. Samuel Eliot Morison, historian of Harvard, edited the following: the Harvard College Charter of 1650, Chesholme’s Steward’s Book, 1651–1660, President Dunster’s Quadriennium Memoir, 1654, Jonathan Mitchell’s Modell, c. 1663, the College Laws of 1655, 1692, and 1767, and the College Customs of 1734/5. Benjamin Wadsworth’s Book, 1725–1736, was edited by Clifford K. Shipton, and George L. Kittredge edited two orations, one (1652) by Nathaniel Rogers, father of President John, and one (1677) by President Urian Oakes. All of the documents are in the University Archives, with the exception of the Rogers oration, which is at the New England Historic Genealogical Society, and the Mitchell Modell, located at the Massachusetts Archives.

By the early 1940s, Clifford K. Shipton, who was by then Archivist of Harvard, suggested it would be appropriate for the Colonial Society to publish a volume of Harvard documents before 1750, to supplement the record books already published. He found a willing helper in Lawrence Shaw Mayo, who retired as Associate Dean of the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences in 1943. Mayo, who had studied and written about Lord Jeffrey Amherst, John Wentworth, John Endicott, John Langdon, and the Winthrops, was well versed in seventeenth and eighteenth-century New England. Together Shipton and Mayo selected, from the various series of papers in the Harvard Archives, documents which seemed worthy of reproduction. The nature of the material will be discussed later. Photostats were made, and I, then on the staff of the Harvard Archives, was engaged to make typed transcripts. Little did I think, in 1946 and 1947, that I would be doing the final editing over twenty-five years later. Mayo made preliminary editorial comments and identifications on yellow sheets attached to the first 126 documents; then, on 23 July 1947 occurred his untimely death. The photostats, with the completed transcripts, remained in the care of the Society’s Editor, at the Boston Athenæum, until the Society determined it could publish another title in the Harvard series; and early in 1971 the work of editing began.

In making their selection, Messrs. Shipton and Mayo omitted items already in print in accessible places. Thus the Harvard Charters and the various versions of the Laws could be passed over; certain of these, in fact, were in the Society’s volume xxxi, as was noted above. Routine financial documents and routine lands papers, often in nearly illegible condition, were omitted, as were some copies of deeds, in which the College was not one of the parties. But nearly all of one key series (the College Papers), and substantial portions of certain other series are included.1 Some observations on the physical make-up of these papers, as they exist in the Harvard Archives, may be useful here. The College Papers, a chronological collection of letters and documents, were first bound under President Sparks, who served from 1849 to 1853; volume I (1650–1763) is the one with which we are most concerned, plus a few items in a supplementary volume, bound in the 1890s. Handwritten explanatory notes, arranged in the sequence of the documents, constitute a Calendar volume which, allowing for some errors, is still useful. Papers which turned up after the original volumes and their supplements were bound were placed about 1933 by the Archives staff in a series known as Corporation Papers; a considerable number of items from this grouping are also included herein. A collection of documents relating to the Fellowship controversy of 1720–1723, transcribed and annotated by Albert Matthews, constitutes a unit of unbound papers; many are included here. Another grouping, known as Disorders Papers, contributed only one document, but that a long one, containing depositions on the antics of a few students in 1676.

Documents relating to College lands are in a number of series in the Archives. Those in bound volume I are well covered here, and there are a few pieces from Volume II; arrangement of the contents, which date from 1647, is by land holding, and there is a calendar in the back of each volume. There are sufficient documents relating to some holdings to constitute separate collections, and one of these, Narragansett Farm, has its own manuscript volume, with calendar. While on the subject of property, a few deeds, taken from a collection bearing that title, and divided into a seventeenth-century and an eighteenth-century series, have been included.

Gifts to the College, in addition to land, are well covered, with selections from series titled Donation Lists (1680–), Gift Papers (1643–) and Wills Papers (1660–). The letters and papers of Thomas Hollis and his immediate heirs constitute a separate volume (1718–1744), while certain letters from Thomas Hollis to President Leverett and to Professor Wigglesworth are in still another volume (1718–1735). Collections of Presidents’ Papers, gathered for the most part by the Archives in the present century, are well represented. Documents relating to Henry Dunster are the most numerous, but there are also letters and papers of Increase Mather, John Leverett, and Edward Holyoke in the following pages.

Reluctantly, no attempt has been made to include documents relating to Harvard in other depositories, except for a few items, of which copies already exist in the Harvard Archives. To have attempted to include papers relating to Harvard in the State Archives and the Middlesex County Court, in the New England Historic Genealogical Society (the Ewer ms), the Massachusetts Historical Society (the Washburn and other collections), and the Boston Public Library, to mention but the most obvious, would have unduly extended these volumes, both in size and in time required for completion. References to a few such documents may be found in the notes.

I have sketched briefly the physical arrangement in the Harvard Archives of the originals of these documents. I would next turn to a consideration of the content, indicating a few of the highlights, in chronological sequence. A number of the earliest documents are from the papers of Henry Dunster, resulting from an attempt of his stepchildren to obtain an accounting of their mother’s estate. In addition to family matters, they reveal much about the financial affairs of the College under Dunster, as well as the business affairs of the Press. In 1652 the General Court asked the towns for voluntary contributions to the College; a dozen or more replies, some sending gifts, and some begging off, may be found herein. In the latter part of the century the documents become much more varied in nature, but a common thread may be found in the activities of President Increase Mather. His concern about the lack of a Royal Charter (the Charter of 1650 was vacated in 1684 and was not resumed until 1707), his threats to resign, arrangements for his salary, and problems raised by his reluctance to live in Cambridge, all are touched upon in these documents. Five letters from Mather to Sir William Ashurst, recently acquired by the Harvard Archives, have been added. Mather’s handwriting could be quite difficult, and there are more doubtful words in his drafts than in most of the papers included herein.

With the election of President Leverett and the restoration of the 1650 Charter, both occurring in 1707, the College seemed to be settled on an even keel. But Leverett himself soon met with opposition, part of it political in origin. Early in the 1720s occurred the Fellowship controversy, when Tutor Nicholas Sever tried to prove that the Tutors should of right be Fellows of the Corporation. In his long and closely reasoned essays, Sever went back into the history of the College; he also reveals, in passing, the training Harvard students of his time received in argumentation.1 A large proportion of the documents of the 1720s relate to the gifts of Thomas Hollis, Sr. (actually the second Thomas) to the College; there are over ninety letters from him, fifty-four of them to Benjamin Colman. In his letters Hollis reveals himself as a practical, yet liberal businessman; one learns much from the letters about the English Dissenting community. Of particular interest are the many books which he gave, or persuaded his friends to give, to the College library; I have tried, where possible, to identify the authors and titles. One comes on the last letter which Hollis sent to Cambridge with a feeling of regret, as at losing the acquaintance of a good man. Another thread tying together documents of the late 1720s is the effort of Timothy Cutler and Samuel Myles, Church of England ministers in Boston, to obtain seats on the Board of Overseers; they wrote letters and petitioned, but in vain.

While Leverett was still President, Tutor Flynt began to track down the history of gifts made to Harvard; President Wadsworth encouraged further effort along these lines. Some Harvard lands, such as Merricaneag Neck in Harpswell, Maine, or Narragansett Farm, in North Kingston, Rhode Island, were distant from Cambridge and difficult to manage. The Merricaneag land in the end was lost to squatters, but the College encouraged tenant farmers in North Kingston, even to the extent of providing them with buildings. There were problems too over the College land in Rowley, left by the Rev. Ezekiel Rogers in 1660. In the 1730s the College petitioned the General Court to be allowed to sell the land; this was granted, and the proceeds were invested in a farm in Waltham, henceforth called the Rogers Farm. Efforts to obtain some benefit from College-owned lands and from unfulfilled gifts gave rise to many of the documents dating from the second quarter of the eighteenth century.

There are references within to the 1972 Harvard thesis by John M. Hoffmann, titled, Commonwealth College: The Governance of Harvard in the Puritan Period. In his appendix E, “Early Sources: College Books I–III,” the author painstakingly reconstructs the missing College Book II, and brings new insights to bear on the date and circumstances of the compilation of College Book III. It is appropriate that this Appendix should appear as an addition to the present volumes, for it will bring within the Colonial Society’s Harvard series currently available information on the early Harvard record books.

Thus users of these volumes will find a great variety of topics covered, from the Stephen Day indenture of 1638 to the Peter Reynolds lease of 1750. In many cases, the complete story will not be found here, but there will be enough information to make a start, among other sources and other depositories.

Arrangement

The arrangement of the documents in these volumes is for the most part chronological; exceptions are minor and should be quite clear, as when papers relating to the disposition of Hollis’s first gift, covering only a few months, are grouped in sequence. Early documents copied for use at a later date, such as some of those by Nicholas Sever, are placed under the early date, but with a note as to their origin. Some of the documents in the original selection were found to be duplicated, and were omitted; a few others were combined with ones to which they were related. Each document has been numbered consecutively, and given an assigned title. The date appears in the upper right, unless it is clearly indicated in the first line or two of the text. It is placed in brackets, if supplied, or taken from elsewhere in the document; if taken from the end, it is then omitted there. The double year, i.e., 1734/35, is shown between January 1 and March 25. Following the end of the document, endorsements, if they corroborate or provide additional information, are transcribed. If, in the case of letters, there is an address, it follows next; it has seemed desirable to include this, as it sometimes provides additional information and also serves as indication that the item is the recipient’s copy. All notes are placed at the end of each document. First comes a general descriptive note, giving the location of the original, and indication of its condition, if damaged, reference to where it may be available in print, and identification of the key persons or circumstances involved. Footnotes, if any, follow; these may identify other persons mentioned, especially Harvard graduates. The latter are always identified by date of graduation or class, in parentheses. Special topics of interest, or peculiarities of the text, may also be referred to in footnotes.

Transcription

General

The style of transcription is a moderately literal one. In each case the original documents in the Harvard Archives were checked again. The original spelling has been kept, except in the case of abbreviations, discussed below. If necessary, periods and capitals have been added to indicate sentences; Hollis, for instance, made frequent use of dashes, and most of these have been omitted. In the case of some lengthy items, paragraphing has been supplied. Again, in the case of lengthy documents, the page numbers of the original have been indicated within brackets. Practices, now common, for indicating words which could not be deciphered, words questioned or supplied, or words crossed out have been followed; these symbols are shown following the introduction. The monetary symbols, £, s, d, are everywhere so shown; sums have been checked by addition, where possible. An attempt has been made to show signatures signed by “mark.” Interlineations are indicated, by means of a footnote, only if in a different hand. In some legal documents, phraseology, common to all such papers, has been omitted; omission is indicated by three dots and is always remarked on in the descriptive note. An effort has been made to keep informality, especially in the case of letters; for example, contractions, such as ’em for them, or preferr’d, for preferred have been kept.

Abbreviations

Most abbreviations have been expanded, with the superscript letters brought down. The symbol & has been transcribed as and, except in &c., or in the name of a company. The word ye has been always shown as the, and thô has been written out as though. In expanding words, an effort has been made to follow the spelling of the time; thus hon^ble becomes honourable, and gov^r, governour, at least until 1725 or thereabout. If only the first few letters of a word are given, the remainder may be expanded, but in brackets. For example, coll becomes coll[ege]; this is in part to show the informal use of the abbreviation, and also because the word was often spelled colledge then, and one cannot be sure how an individual writer would have completed it. Abbreviations of common titles, such as Mr., Capt., and the like, have been kept. The commonly used Esq^r is shown as the modern Esq.; on the other hand, Rev^d is written out as Reverend, for I feel sure the modern Rev. would have seemed disrespectful then. Months, if abbreviated, are so shown; however, one written with a superscript letter, as Dec^r is expanded to December. The period frequently placed after the day and year is omitted. First names have been expanded, unless they are in signatures or representations of such; abbreviated names in salutations of the Hollis letters have also been kept. A few common abbreviations, some of them found in legal documents, have been retained, as mo. for month, pa. for page, do. for ditto, or J. Pac. for Justice of the Peace. The idea has been to make abbreviations understandable without being pedantic.

Acknowledgments

I am grateful to the Harvard Business School for allowance of time, up to a day a week, for work on this project. I am glad to acknowledge the assistance of the staff of the Harvard University Archives, headed when I began these transcriptions, in the late forties, by Clifford K. Shipton, and more recently by Kimball C. Elkins and Harley P. Holden; without their generous help this work could not have been completed. Walter M. Whitehill, Editor of the Colonial Society, guided me through the intricacies of preparing material for the press, and has also kindly written the Foreword to these volumes. Harry N. Milliken, of The Anthoensen Press, handled what proved to be difficult material in a most effective way. The Meriden Gravure Company prepared the plates for the maps. Daniel K. Clift, graduate student in the Classics, helped to make sure the Latin was correct and provided translations, where necessary. John M. Hoffmann gave me the benefit of his knowledge of early Harvard, and as I have noted, has contributed the Appendix to these volumes. Eleanor C. Bishop, my assistant, helped identify an occasional difficult name or word, by means of her knowledge of local genealogy and familiarity with difficult handwriting. My wife, Dorothy, ably and cheerfully assisted me in the proofreading. I like to think that these volumes may be of some lasting use to the staff of the Harvard Archives, if only to prevent wear and tear of the originals, and to students of early Harvard. As my years at the University, most of them spent at the Business School, come closer to their end, I am happy for this connection with the Harvard Archives, with which my career as librarian-archivist began.

Robert W. Lovett

Curator of Manuscripts and

Archives, Baker Library

Beverly, Massachusetts

January, 1975

1. A helpful listing of the main records series (to 1800) in the Harvard Archives is in Appendix F of Samuel E. Morison’s Harvard College in the Seventeenth Century (Cambridge, 1936), vol. II, 662–81; changes have not been sufficient to outdate it seriously.

1. Many of his papers were published in J. E. Kirkpatrick’s Academic Organization and Control (Yellow Springs, Ohio, 1931), but that volume is not easily available now, and it contains some errors and omissions, so they are reprinted here.

1. Words following the signatures of witnesses are hard to decipher. Preice and Colbron are followed by “Ser” and a letter, possibly Latin for Ser [vus]; Nelmes is followed by a word appearing to end in “ieu”.

1. For another payment to “Mr. Eldred for shooes” see Morison, Founding, p. 273.

2. Lockrum was a linen fabric.

3. Difficulty of interpreting a few figures makes the total slightly less than the sumas recorded.

1. Segs are animals castrated when fully grown.

2. A tear in the MS makes a half dozen words illegible.

1. Several lines, in the hand of Governor Winthrop, are not readily legible.

1. Nathaniel Ward (c. 1578–1652), one-time minister at Ipswich and author of The Simple Cobbler of Aggawam. He returned to England in the winter of 1646–1647. See CSM Publications, xv. 176; also Morison, Founding, pp. 403–404.

2. Capt. Robert Cook; the non-receipt of this grant is referred to in CSM Publications, xv. 284.

3. John Doddridge, Esq. (d. 1659) “of Bremeridge in the County of Devon.” For the terms of this bequest, see CSM Publications, XV. 289; and for its abandonment by the College, xvi. 654. A copy of his Will is in No. 60 following.

4. Robert Sedgwick (c. 1613–1656) of Charlestown, who was chosen Major-General of the Colony in 1652, and later became one of Cromwell’s major-generals. In 1646 he gave the College “two shops standing by the ordinary called the Ship’s Tavern, under lease for fifteen years at ten shillings sterling.” For a biographical sketch of Sedgwick see CSM Publications, iii. 156–173.

5. William Phillips (d. 1683). See CSM Publications, XV. 286–287.

1. Samuel Sewall, the well-known judge and diarist, graduated in the Class of 1671. Further documents relating to Merricaneag Neck appear later in this volume.

2. For more on John Newgate and his deed of gift see No. 11.

3. John Cogan’s gift of Rumney Marsh, in what is now Revere, is noted in Morison, Seventeenth Century, I. 34–35.

4. Samuel Ward’s gift is noted further in Nos. 84 and 85.

5. See No. 70 for an enlarged quote from Theodore Atkinson’s deed. The last three entries (Atkinson, Rutland, and Groton) appear in almost the same form in CSM Publications, xv. 279–280, 285; they are from College Book III.

1. John Glover, merchant; see Morison, Seventeenth Century, ii. 380. His son graduated from the College in 1651; not to be confused with the John Glover who was Dunster’s stepson.

2. John Walley died in 1712.

3. For Henry Webb’s bequest see Morison, Seventeenth Century, ii. 379. His Will is in New England Historical and Genealogical Register, x (April, 1856), 177.

4. For a further extract from James Penn’s Will see No. 69.

5. Thomas Richards, nephew and heir of Major John Richards, died in Boston on December 5, 1714.

6. The Will of Robert Keayne, wealthy merchant, has been written about often. For what happened to his Harvard bequest see Morison, Seventeenth Century, ii. 378–379.

1 Probably a symbol.

1 We would say stepfather.

2 The initials stand for Thomas Danforth who, in addition to many duties connected with the College, was clerk of courts.

1 Adam and Deane Winthrop were sons of Governor John Winthrop.

2 This is a legal symbol.

3 For a reference by Dunster to a return made by these men see No. 39.

1 This line is in a different hand.

1 This sentence is in a different hand.

1 Many words are crossed out, including “with the greatest expedition that may be.”

2 In margin: [Fellow?]

[Eldest?]	12
2–	10
3–	8
4–	6
	36

1 The ‘5’ has been written over; to make the addition correct, it should probably be a ‘4’.

2 Should be 233:10:3.

1 The ‘13’ has been written over to make it ‘03’.

1 “Mr. Allen” was presumably the Reverend Thomas Allen, of Charlestown, who married John Harvard’s widow and acted as executor of his Will. See Morison, Founding, pp. 222, 364.

2 It looks as though 300 has been changed to 301; the latter sum is needed to make the total correct. Some figures have been reworked in the original; there are additional figures on the page, and some have been crossed out.

1 The figure ‘17’ in the total was changed to ‘13’.

1 For Eaton see the note to No. 31.

1 William Hibbins; also spelled Hibbens or Hibbings.

1 See No. 36 for the names of persons so designated.

2 Presumably the initials T.D. stand for Thomas Danforth, who had been one of the attorneys for the children of Jose Glover.

1 For their appointment see No. 13.

2 Probably a legal symbol.

1 For Dunster’s resignation as President of Harvard see Morison, Seventeenth Century, I. 307–314.

2 The answer of the Court to the first three points may be found in Chaplin, op cit, p. 149, and in Quincy, History, I. 465–466.

1 Samuel Dunster, op cit, feels that Coy stands for Kay, and says that Dunster’s mother’s maiden name was Kay.

2 There were several Thomas Greenes at this time; many English Greenes settled in Barbadoes about 1635. See Lora S. LaMance, The Greene Family and Its Branches, p. 39.

3 Guinea.

1 This and the following column do not add up correctly.

1 Day brought a separate suit against Dunster for £100; this was decided for the defendant; see David Pulsifer, transcripts of documents in Middlesex County Court, I. 94. See also G. P. Winship, The Cambridge Press, p. 140.

1 Messrs. Hibbens (probably Hibbings) and Lowell were attorneys for the Glover heirs; see G. P. Winship, The Cambridge Press, p. 139.

2 This had been the Day house; it was sold by Dunster to John Fownall before March, 1647–1648, when he bought it back. See Morison, Founding, p. 346, n. 4.

1 ‘Judgeth’ is written over this word.

1 Sara Bucknam was 84 years old, and had been a servant to Mrs. Glover 1¼ years; see Anna Glover, Glover Memorials and Genealogies, p. 570.

1 In error for £232; figures above were changed; figures on the next page indicate that £232, not £252, is correct.

2 This may be a symbol.

1 It appears that this should be £678.10.00.

2 These sums are scratched out; however, the arithmetic requires this amount.

3 Portions of these sums are also scratched out; again, the figuring requires this amount.

1 This sum should be £189–15–09.

2 Tears or erasures obscure the first figure in this and two subsequent entries; they have been supplied from entries in other documents.

3 The ‘1’ in this and the following entry is ambiguous; other documents list returns from the Press as £50.

4 The total appears to be £60 too low; however, some figures are ambiguous.

1 A few proper names are identifiable, as Nowell and T. D. Recorder; this was probably Thomas Danforth.

1 The first paragraph has been omitted, since it contains shorthand and is the same as the second paragraph.

* Also a silver tankard in kind.

Also Mr. Glovers books according to Cattologue given in to be delivered in kind.

Also the price of a house at Hingham that was received of Payntare at £15.

[.] Also to Mr. Dunster the lands in Sudbury bounds purchased by the said Henry Dunster called the farme now in the occupation of Wilson.

1 These words appear to be altered from ‘revealed’ and ‘revealing.’

2 There is a caret, but the copyist neglected to put in the word, doubtless ‘set’.

1 From the second copy, it appears that Jeremiah Ellsworth was added later.

1 The words from “President” to “Society” appear to be in a different hand, as is also the case when they appear below.

1 Saltonstall recommended Knowles for the College Presidency in 1672, but nothing came of it.

1 “The Doctor” was President Hoar.

2 Elijah Corlet, the Cambridge schoolmaster, and his son, Ammi Ruhamah (A.B. 1670). For a brief sketch of Elijah see Morison, Founding, p. 373.

1 The house to which he refers was Old Harvard Hall, begun in 1674.

1 Alexander’s testimony is squeezed in between Abdere’s and Warrar’s, and is in a different hand.

2 The numbers refer to the pages in the original; they are shown in this copy within brackets.

1 This inscription is written across the back; the blurring makes it almost impossible to read. This reading is taken from a transcription in the Harvard Archives.

1 William Manning, the builder.

2 Cambridge Village, now Brighton.

3 Sums as shown add up to £155.13s.4d.

4 Entries for Springfield, Northampton, and Bradford are crossed out, since they appear above.

5 Capt. John Richards, Mr. Anthony Stoddard, Capt. Thomas Brattle.

1 Several words are missing, due to a tear in the margin.

1 Samuel Torrey, minister of Weymouth, was a member of the Class of 1650, but did not graduate; he declined the offer of the Presidency.

1 Stanislaw Lubienski, Theatrum Cometicum, issued in three parts, 1666–1668.

2 Gijsbert Voet, Exercitatio de Prognosticis Cometarum, 1665.

3 Harvard’s set of the Miscellanea is listed in the 1723 Library Catalogue as extending, in three series, from 1670 to 1694.

1 A piece is here cut out and a blank inserted.

2 Samuel Sewall, an Overseer by virtue of being a magistrate, graduated with the Class of 1671.

1 This clause, from “the remainder” is in a different hand.

2 The students were: Henry Gibbs (A.B. 1685), Nathaniel Rogers (A.B. 1687), Jonathan Mitchell (A.B. 1687), and Paul Dudley (A.B. 1690, the Governor’s son).

3 The “K” has been written over what appears to be an “L”. This correction, the clause in number 1, and the date may have been added by either Dudley or Stoughton.

1 Rev. John Sherman died in 1685; see John Eliot, A Biographical Dictionary . . . , pp. 427–428. The phrase, “who is since that dead,” is inserted in a different hand.

2 No new Fellows were appointed until 1690, and Samuel Sewall, having served in 1673–1674, did not again become one.

1 In No. 160 Henry Newman gives the name as Isaac Brackston.

1 “my selfe” was John Richards, Treasurer.

1 Written over “Kingston”, the first part of which is crossed out. Thomas Gunston, of Newington Green, gave £50.

1 This appears to be £180, not £150; however, other documents of about this time indicate the President received £100, plus £50 in country pay.

1 Col. Samuel Shrimpton owned considerable property in Boston; see Justin Winsor, ed., The Memorial History of Boston, 1. 584; also Bernard Bailyn, The New England Merchants in the Seventeenth Century, pp. 192–193.

1 The second version adds “to me”.

2 The second version substitutes “have not manifested any consent”.

3 The second version adds, omits, or changes slightly in the next few lines as follows: “And considering that the Council on this occasion, the matter layd before them by the Honourable Lieut. Governor, would not agree to desire me to continue my cares of the Colledge any longer, as hitherto. These unkindnesses (after all my weary Endeavours to serve them abroad and at home) have made such an Impression upon my spirit, as that I cannot be willing to be any Longer concerned as President of the Colledge . . . .”

4 The second version substitutes “upon them, that have cast these Discouragements before me”.

1 In Nos. 1a and 1b the “further” appears before “Serviceable” rather than before “Prospect”.

2 In the plural (“Cares”) in versions 1a, 1b and 2.

3 “Clamours” in versions 1a and 1b.

4 No. 2 adds a sentence (crossed out): Especially I take it unkindly, that One lately admitted a member of the Corporation should so reward me.

5 In place of the clause, “and before effectuall . . . Presidentship”, Nos. 1a and 1b state, in reference to the confirmation of the charter, “which thing was ever doubtful to me”.

6 In Nos. 1a, 1b, and 2 the following sentences are inserted: And having a Desire now Age is come upon me, to live with all the Privacy and Retirement among my own people that is possible. Also foreseeing, That in all Probability, another Dissolution not to be Retrieved, will ‘ere long happen to the Corporation; I am not willing that that Ruin should be under my Hand. In version 3, in place of the above two sentences is this lengthy statement: And whereas the Church, to which I am related, have unanimously signified, that they cannot consent to my Removal to Cambridge, unless I shall continue my Relation to them, and preach the Word amongst them as oft as I can. And considering that I have freely offered, upon my Removal to the Colledge, daily to inspect and govern that Society, and to moderate the Disputations of the Graduates, as former Presidents used to do, and to preach publickly, in Cambridge, every Lord’s Day (which things are work enough for one man, especially One in years, as I am), And moreover for the satisfaction of my own people, In Boston, to preach to them once a fortnight, as long as the Lord shall enable me, and although I understand, that my Loving people are, on this Condition, willing to continue my present maintenance, I have absolutely declined to receive one penny from them, after my residing in Cambridge, being willing to refuse £160 per annum when thus freely tendered to me, and to continue my Labours with my Dear Flock for no other reason in the World, but that so I might manifest my Love to them, and be instrumental of good to their souls. And whereas I supposed this Offer of mine would have been joyfully accepted by every One concerned in the Colledge, but it has not so. And whereas it has been said, That if I would Resign the Presidentship, the Colledge would soon be settled with another President and a good one too, and that my pretending a Readiness to Resign was but a Flourish.

7 Nos. 1a, 1b and 2 use the phrase, “for these causes”.

8 The date is scratched out, and most of Mather’s signature torn off. The text itself is not in his hand.

1 In place of “afternoon”, crossed out.

2 This is interlined, in place of “every morning” at the end of the sentence, which is crossed out.

3 The Tutors were Jabez Fitch (A.B. 1694) and Ebenezer Pemberton (A.B. 1691).

4 This whole paragraph is crossed out, and the next one substituted.

1 The initials have been interpreted as Nehemiah Hobart (A.B. 1667), Nehemiah Walter (A.B. 1684), and possibly Samuel Danforth (A.B. 1683).

1 May be translated: my strength and mind being weak.

1 The sentence to this point is inserted in a different hand, evidently Increase Mather’s.

2 Taking the right of visitation out of the hands of the Governor was a sure way of incurring a Royal veto.

3 This paragraph is crossed out.

1 Hubbard should be Hobart.

2 Senior Tutors were Jabez Fitch (A.B. 1694) and Henry Flynt (A.B. 1693).

1 The initials stand for State Papers, Office of Board of Trade.

2 Richard Coote, Earl of Bellomont, was Royal Governor in 1699 and 1700. His letter of July 15, 1700 is printed in Morison, Seventeenth Century, ii. 528–529.

3 Sir Henry Ashurst (d. 1711) was a Colonial Agent, and was active in the New England Company.

1 William Brattle (A.B. 1680) was a Fellow from 1685 to 1700 and from 1703 to 1717, and Treasurer from 1713 to 1715; he was minister in Cambridge.

2 This was Samuel Willard, who remained as Vice-President until just before his death in 1707.

3 Nehemiah Hobart (A.B. 1667) had been a Fellow from 1681 to 1692 and was reappointed in the Charter of 1697, serving until 1712; he was minister in Newton.

1 This phrase is substituted, in Increase Mather’s hand, for “thereof”, crossed out.

2 This clause is substituted, in Increase Mather’s hand, for “on such as they shallfind duely qualified for them”, crossed out.

1 At top: “suppose 1704”.

2 The words “prelector or” are crossed out.

3 The word “Lecturer” is crossed out.

1 Gate: right to a run or pasture on a common field.

1 Probably Sir Charles Hobby (d. 1715), friend of the Mathers.

1 Constantine Phips; see No. 140.

2 William Blathwayt; see No. 138.

3 Lord Bellomont, Governor, 1699–1700.

4 Mather was offered the presidency in 1681, but he did not actually become President until 1685.

1 Thomas Dudley signed the Charter of 1650.

2 Joannes C. Itter, Diatriba de Gradibus Academicis . . . Giessae, 1679, and Frankfurti, 1698. Mentioned also by Cotton Mather in No. 163.

1 This figure should be £363.09.065 it is correctly given in another copy to be found in Lands Papers, ii. 33.

1 In margin: Promoted the choice of another. Sam.

2 Slightly different texts of Mather’s degree can be found in B. Peirce, History of Harvard University, Appendix, p. 52, drawn from Mather’s Magnalia, B. iv. 132–134.

* Five Years are not yet expired since you were pleased unanimously to invite me to accept of the Pastoral office over You. But the unwillingness of the Dear People among whom I have been labouring in the Gospel for the space of thirty six Years, that I should leave them, in consideration with some other obstacles kept me from complying with that your loving motion—sixteen years will this summer be lapsed since God by his Providence devolved the Presidentship of that Society into my Hands to manage it for the ends which he did at first erect a College in N.E. upon.

3 Should be November 7.

1 In the sense of grateful appreciation; see The Oxford English Dictionary.

1 Probably Andrew Belcher, merchant, who died in 1717.

2 Probably Jeremiah Dummer, who died in 1718.

3 Edward Chamberlayne (d. 1703) issued several editions of Anglaiae Notitia; or the Present State of England. His son, John, took it over and expanded it to Magnae Britanniae Notitia; or the Present State of Great Britain.

4 Thomas Wardapiet received an honorary Doctor of Divinity degree from Oxford University on May 29, 1707; he was Archbishop of St. Crux in Goethan, Greater Armenia.

1 Probably Andrew Bordman, Steward, 1703–1747.

1 “Scientia” is here inserted and crossed out.

1 Samuel Sewall (A.B. 1671) was both secretary and treasurer of the Commissioners for Indian Affairs at this time; the Commissioners were charged with distributing the funds raised by the New England Company.

2 Joseph Dudley (A.B. 1665). These letters reflect the Mathers’ feud with the Dudleys, feelings which came to include President Leverett, who had Dudley’s support.

1 Robert Boyle (d. 1691), eminent scientist, and first governor of the New England Company. Arrangements for the College’s receiving its half of the pertinent part of his legacy are noted in Mather’s letter to Ashurst of November 8, 1710, following.

1 Acts and Resolves, ix. 105–108.

1 For an extract from Robert Thorner’s Will see No. 97.

2 Awnsham Churchill (d. 1728).

1 Jeremiah Dummer (A.B. 1699). Acts and Resolves, IX. 154, 156–158.

2 Sir Henry Ashurst (d. 1711), Sir William’s brother.

3 The Commissioners were directed in 1697 to make annual payments to the College of £45, representing one-half the income of an English estate purchased by the New England Company with monies left by Boyle. The money was to be used to pay two ministers for teaching Indians in or near the College. As Mather indicates, the College had not received this money, and in 1710 the College and the Commissioners came to an agreement about it. See CSM Publications, XV. 393–394. This matter is also discussed in William Kellaway, The New England Company, 1649–1776 (London, 1961), pp. 173–175. This volume is most useful for an account of persons involved, not only in London, but in the Colonies. And on page 175 is a quotation from another letter from Increase Mather to Sir William Ashurst, dated 10 January 1710/11. The source for the quotation (a modern transcript) is given as MS 8010, Miscellaneous papers, 1706–1806, Guildhall Library.

4 Robert Thompson; see mention of Madam Thompson, Lady Ashurst’s mother, in No. 177A. Joseph Thompson, Treasurer of the New England Company from 1702 to 1720, was a brother-in-law of Sir William Ashurst.

5 This was to be the third edition, but it did not appear. See Kellaway (cited above), pp. 156–159.

1 The preceding list gives him as William.

1 Mather received a Doctor of Divinity degree from the University of Glasgow in 1710; see Sibley, Sketches, iii. 39. The text of the degree is given in CSM Publications, xv. 308.

2 This work is mentioned in No. 144.

3 A bit of Hebrew is here inserted.

1 Thomas Brattle (A.B. 1676), former College Treasurer, died in 1713.

2 Thomas Hollis (died 1731), London merchant, was the leading benefactor of the College at this time; he will be met with frequently in this volume.

3 William Brattle (A.B. 1680), brother of Thomas, and also College Treasurer, died in 1717.

4 John Walley, of Boston, died in 1712.

5 Charles Chauncy (A.B. 1721).

6 Ebenezer Pemberton (A.B. 1721).

1 Possibly the John Chamberlayne whose books were sent to the College; see No. 151.

2 Jeremiah Dummer (A.B. 1699) was by this time Agent for the Colony in London. For his services to Yale see Sibley, Sketches (Shipton), iv. 462–464.

3 This was The New England Company.

1 Benjamin Marston’s wife, Patience, and John Leverett’s wife, Margaret, were sisters.

1 It was John Newgate, not Nathaniel; for his gift see No. 11.

2 For John Glover and his gift see No. 8.

1 A Richard Syles appears in the Rowley Vital Records for this period.

2 In subsequent years the name was Timothy Pamer (or Palmer).

1 John Gunston became Treasurer of the New England Company in 1720.

2 A half dozen words are illegible because of a tear in the MS.

1 The month appears to be missing, because of the torn margin.

1 William Tailer, who served as Lt. Governor of Massachusetts, 1711–1716 and 1730–1732.

1 Ebenezer Pierpont (A.B. 1715), who took Sever to Court over a College dispute; see No. 185 for Sevens defense.

2 It appears that Sever received a call to Tiverton, but he had given up preaching, because of a strain to his vocal cords. See Sibley, Sketches (Shipton), v. 91.

1 Crossed out: “for the Law no where Requires that a Legatee shal demand [. . .] or any Such Legacy, of the Executors before”.

2 Crossed out: “was long Since obliged at his Peril to have deliver’d the Tankard to the Appellees tho’ they had not demanded”.

3 Crossed out: “where there is no more by Such a Limitation than is to be found in [Mr. Mitchel’s] Will”.

4 Crossed out: “pretence”.

5 Crossed out: “such a”.

6 Crossed out: “the Executrix or her husband”.

7 Crossed out: “[with]out having any more demand than”.

8 Crossed out: “them”.

9 Crossed out: “fair and”.

10 Crossed out: “never heard of”.

11 Crossed out: “his Last Will and Testament”.

12 Crossed out: “procure”.

13 Crossed out: “Such person has told ’em plainly that”.

14 Crossed out: “The Appellees pray your Honours patience that they may dis”.

15 Crossed out: “But that of”.

16 Crossed out: “Assigned”.

17 Crossed out: “which the Gentlewoman Assented to and Conveyed the Consider able part of her Inheritance for and At the Same time advanced the Value of the Remaining part of her Inheritance, which he left to her, to the Value of the Whole Viz. £400”.

18 The remaining part of the document is missing.

1 Thomas Pierpont (A. B. 1721).

2 This section is written in reverse on the first sheet, with several interlineations and deletions.

3 Amos Throop and Jabez or John Wight, all A. B. 1721. The last names are taken from D, a portion omitted in the following.

4 William Brattle (A. B. 1722).

5 Thomas Parker (A. B. 1718). Sir in front of his name is crossed out.

6 John Wolcott (A. B. 1721).

7 John Wentworth (A. B. 1721).

8 Samuel Marshall (A. B. 1721).

9 Pascal Nelson (A. B. 1721).

10 Joseph Gooch (A. B. 1720); also written as Gouge.

11 Joshua Lamb; died while a student, a member of the Class of 1723.

12 This was evidently a meeting of the President and Resident Fellows, not of the Corporation.

13 Probably Josiah Winslow, who was restored to his Class. See Sibley, Sketches (Shipton), vi. 587.

14 Probably Mitchel Sewall (A. B. 1718), who was named College Butler in 1720.

15 The first portion of this document is omitted here, since it repeats complaints already noted.

16 May be translated: Be of brave spirit, since you are unjustly damned. No one rejoices for long, who wins out by unjust judgement.

17 Possibly Stephen Sewall (A. B. 1721).

18 Judah Monis, Instructor in Hebrew.

19 Jonathan Bowman (A. B. 1724).

20 James Osgood (A. B. 1724).

21 Probably Marston Cabot (A. B. 1724).

22 C. and M., as well as B. and M. above, are not identified.

23 Probably Mitchel Sewall, College Butler, mentioned above.

1 William Heath (died 1741), of Roxbury.

2 The Class of 1720.

3 Probably Peleg Heath, who graduated from Yale in 1721.

4 Probably Francis Foxcroft (A.B. 1712).

5 Evidently a reference to New Haven, where the son had been a student.

1 Crossed out: “drawn”.

2 Benjamin Lynde (A.B. 1686), brother to Hannah, who was Jonathan Mitchell’s widow and the future Mrs. Goffe.

3 Mrs. Jonathan Mitchell.

4 Patience Marston was Mrs. Leverett’s sister; see No. 169 for another reference to her.

1 I am indebted to Daniel K. Clift for identification of these lines as being taken from Horace ep. 1.1.60–61. May be translated: let this be the bronze wall (i.e. defense against life’s ills), that one not be conscious of guilt, nor be there guilt to pale one.

1 Should be 11½.

1 Crossed out: “against”.

2 Possibly Edmund Goffe, the subject of earlier letters from Leverett to Sewall.

3 Nicholas Fessenden, Jr. (A.B. 1701), who died on October 5, 1719.

4 Probably Mitchel Sewall (A.B. 1718).

1 See Nos. 7 and 8 for extracts of these wills and deeds: also No. 264.

1 Samuel Mather (A.B. 1723).

2 For Thorner’s gift see No. 97 and No. 160.

3 Written over “Mr. Cradock and Gilbert as before” crossed out.

4 Elisha Callender (A.B. 1710) became minister of the Baptist Church of Boston in 1718. He corresponded with Thomas Hollis; see Sibley, Sketches (Shipton), v. 514.

5 There is a tear in the MS here and in the next line.

6 Ephraim Wheton; see No. 270 for a letter from Hollis to him.

1 Doubdess Samuel Jefferds (A.B. 1722).

1 Hollis must have here meant Benjamin Colman.

1 Rev. Joseph Stevens (A.B. 1703) was a Fellow from 1712 to 1713, and from 1716; he died in 1721.

2 See No. 200 for an account of Browne Family donations, prepared for Tutor Flynt.

1 Paragraph added and crossed out in Supplement I. 40:

Mr. President’s Residence has been mentioned as a reason of the difference in this regard between now and formerly, but if it be considered, that besides prayers and reading in the Hall, Mr. Presidents being here takes off but little of the proper business of the Fellows, We must beg leave to think that our allowance ought not to be shortened so far on that Account, especially since Mr. President is supported by the Government.

2 Phrase added and crossed out in Supplement I. 40:

In as much as by that means our subsistence will lye less heavy upon the College Treasury.

The Penal Law of 1656 is quoted on the back of the draft in Supplement I. 40; this also appears in No. 219 following.

1 Leverett’s wife died on June 7, 1720.

2 See No. 213.

1 Samuel Mather (A.B. 1723).

2 Josiah Dennis (A.B. 1723).

3 John Callender (A.B. 1723).

4 This is apparently a postscript; tears obscure many words.

1 See n. 1 to No. 212.

2 A catalog of the College library was issued in 1723, it was titled: Catalogus Librorum Bibliothecae Collegii Harvardini. It will be cited hereafter as 1723 Catalogus; its arrangement, and that of its two supplements, was alphabetical, by size, with divisions for folios, quartos, and octavos.

3 A Letter to the Rev. Dr. Francis Hare . . . Occasioned by His Reflections on the Dissenters . . . , 1720.

1 Jonathan Belcher (A.B. 1699), the future Governor of Massachusetts.

2 Jeremiah Dummer (also A.B. 1699). For his interest in Yale College see the sketch in Sibley, Sketches (Shipton), iv. 462–464, where a part of this letter is quoted.

1 Benjamin Colman.

2 An error for William Sheafe (A.B. 1723).

3 Hull Abbot (A.B. 1720). He received Hollis aid for two years of graduate study; see Sibley, Sketches (Shipton), vi. 366. Other students mentioned in this letter have been identified earlier.

4 T.S.V.P. is at the bottom of the page, evidently for Turn, if you please. Hollis used this symbol from time to time, and it will not be noted further.

1 Cotton Mather’s The Christian Philosopher: A Collection of the Best Discoveries in Nature, with Religious Improvements, was published in London in 1721; it was dedicated to Thomas Hollis.

2 What remains is written the other way on the sheet.

3 An error for 1720.

* [Words are here crossed out]

* So that as long as persons may be supposed to be governed by the views of future good and Evil, by hope of Favours they are in pursuit of, or by a Fear of the loss of any good they enjoy, that is as long as they may be supposed to love themselves and regard their own interest and happiness, so long the loss of this interest in the College will lessen the Fellows Caracters.

This Sentence comes in between the 23 and 24 lines of the 4th Page.

1 Law 7 of the Penal Laws reads that students were to be “nonplusht” for two days for neglect to read sermons. The exact nature of this punishment is not indicated in the O.E. D. definitions of the word, non-plus.

1 Seth Sweetzer (A.B. 1722) was granted Hollis aid.

2 For Josiah Dennis see note to No. 213.

3 Rev. Daniel Neal (M.A. 1720) married a cousin of Thomas Hollis.

4 Rev. Jeremiah Hunt (1678–1744), minister at Pinner’s Hall, which Hollis’s father had leased.

5 Cave, Latin for warning.

6 Three Letters from New-England, Relating to the Controversy of the Present Time, London, 1721. This contains two letters from Cotton Mather and one from Increase.

7 Additions, sent by later vessel.

8 William Cooper (A.B. 1712) was Colman’s colleague at the Brattle Square Church, Boston. Colman’s sermon at the younger man’s ordination, together with Cooper’s confession of faith, was published in Boston in 1716.

1 Tears in the MS account for the loss of a half dozen words in each of two cases.

1 Daniel Neal; see note to No. 214.

1 Owen received his A.B. in 1723.

2 Charles Chauncy (A.B. 1721) was a great-grandson of President Charles Chauncy.

1 The smallpox epidemic reached its height in Boston in October, 1721.

1 Elihu Yale died on July 8, 1721.

2 William Tailer, twice Lt. Governor.

1 See note to No. 198.

2 Samuel Mather (A.B. 1723).

1 May be translated: as long as you remain here and as long as you are needed here.

1 The list of Treasurers omits William Brattle (A.B. 1680), who served from 1713 to 1715.

1 May be translated: Thus I judge: Responds someone utterly ignorant of the Academics and (let him be) banished from the Academy.

1 From White’s notations on Hollis’s letters, it appears that he had been ailing for some time. He was inoculated against smallpox, and was one of the few, so treated, who died. See Sibley, Sketches, in. 347–348.

2 Edward Hutchinson, who served until his death in 1752.

3 Edward Wigglesworth (A.B. 1710), who served as Hollis Professor of Divinity from 1722 to 1765. The Church referred to was the Old South.

4 Joseph Stevens (A.B. 1703), minister of Charlestown, and Fellow of the Corporation, died of the smallpox on November 16, 1721.

5 Paul Dudley (A.B. 1690) was the son of Governor Joseph and became Chief Justice of Massachusetts.

6 qt. = containing.

7 Both John Owen’s Sermons (London, 1721) and The Poetical Works of Mr John Milton (2 vols., London, 1720) appear in the Supplement to the 1723 Catalogus. The Corporation voted to give Rev. Colman an older edition of Milton in return for this recent one; see CSM Publications, xvi. 466–467.

8 Rev. Daniel Williams, of London, died in 1716. In 1748 the College finally received £48, which was distributed among ministers working with the Indians, in accordance with the donor’s primary wishes. See CSM Publications, xvi. 791, 839–840. An extract of his Will is in No. 162.

1 A Coffe man kept a coffee house. Evidently a book intended for Mr. Harris was somehow mislaid.

2 See note to No. 244.

3 The 1723 Catalogus lists a Theatre of Plants (London, 1640) and a Garden of Flowers (London, 1629), both by John Parkinson.

4 Benjamin Colman, Some Observations on the New Method of Receiving the Small-Pox by Ingrafting or Inoculation . . . Boston, 1721. This was reprinted, with a different title, in London in 1722.

5 William Cooper, A Sermon Conserning the Laying of the Deaths of Others to Heart. Occasion’d by the Lamented Death of . . . John Gore . . . With an Appendix Containing Something of Mr, Gore’s Character . . . Boston, 1720. Gore (A.B. 1702) died of the smallpox on his ship while in Boston harbor; see Sibley, Sketches (Shipton), v. 152–153.

1 The words “of the Charter” are here crossed out.

1 Jeremiah Condy (A.B. 1726).

2 Charles Chauncy (A.B. 1721).

3 Mather Byles (A.B. 1725).

4 Ebenezer Pemberton (A.B. 1721).

5 Leverett took as his second wife Sarah Crisp, widow of William Harris.